Winter Warmers
WBAS Winter 
  Warmers Tasting
8 February 
  2008 at the Loving Arms Pub
 
Brandon and 
  Sarah once again opened The Loving Arms Pub to host a WBAS tasting event. Winter 
  Warmers were the evening fare. The event was conducted as a blind tasting featuring 
  10 representative beers from across the U.S. hand-picked by Dan. 
  

Brandon behind the bar
 
The table below provides some information on the Winter Warmer Line-up
   
    Beer  | 
    Brewery  | 
    Location  | 
    ABV  | 
    Brewer's Description  | 
  
   
    | Stoud's Winter Ale | 
    Stoudt's  | 
    Adamstown, PA | 
    6.0 | 
    This medium to full bodied ale is a deep brown color with notes of chocolate 
      and nut flavors. It has a subtle hop bitterness and chocolaty aroma. This 
      is the perfect holiday beer for the season | 
  
   
    | Smuttynose Winter Ale | 
    Smuttynose  | 
    Portsmouth, NH | 
    not avail | 
    Smuttynose Winter Ale is a full-bodied, amber beer brewed with a special 
      Trappist ale yeast. Stylistically reminiscent of a Belgian Abbey Double, 
      it features fruity aromas and flavor, balanced by soft Crystal hops. Warming, 
      mellow & pleasantly complex | 
  
   
    | Winterbraun | 
    Lost Coast Brwy. & Café | 
    Eureka, CA | 
    6.5 | 
    A full-bodied, brown ale with a rich chocolate taste created from roasted 
      chocolate and caramel malts. Topped with Czech Saaz hops to give it a spicy 
      flavor and aroma.  | 
  
   
    | Bell's Winter White Ale | 
    Bell's  | 
    Comstock, MI | 
    5.0 | 
    Wheat Ale brewed with American Wheat and a proprietary blend of Hefe and 
      classic Belgian-style yeasts. | 
  
   
    | Snow Cap Ale | 
    Pyramid  | 
    Seattle, WA | 
    7.0 | 
    A rich, full-bodied winter warmer crafted in the British tradition of 
      holiday beers. This deep mahogany colored brew balances complex fruit flavors 
      with a refreshingly smooth texture. | 
  
   
    | Winter Solstice Ale | 
    Anderson Valley  | 
    Boonville, CA | 
    6.9 | 
    Winter Solstice Seasonal Ale begins with a very high original gravity 
      to create a hearty and spicy brew with a deep amber hue and a smooth finish. | 
  
   
    | Rouge Ale: Santa's Private Reserve | 
    Oregon  | 
    Newport, OR | 
    6.0 | 
    A variation of the classic Saint Rogue Red, but with double the hops--including 
      Chinook, and Centennial, and a mystery hop called Rudolph by head brewer 
      John "more hops" Maier! This holiday elixir is brewed with two-row 
      Harrington, Klages and Munich malts, along with Hugh Baird 30-37, Carastan 
      13-17, and Crystal 70-80 malts, plus free range coastal water and proprietary 
      top-fermenting Pacman yeast. | 
  
   
    | Winter Storm | 
    Clipper City  | 
    Baltimore, MD | 
    7.5 | 
    Our "winter warmer" ale, brewed with copious helpings of English 
      malts and US and English hops, a ruddy hued "Imperial ESB" in 
      style. Full malty flavors dancing with powerful hop aromas and a lingering, 
      firm hop bitterness. Seasonally available from mid October to February. | 
  
   
    | Celebration Ale | 
    Sierra Nevada  | 
    Chico, CA | 
    6.8 | 
    Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale represents a time honored tradition of brewing 
      a special beer for the holiday season. There are generous portions of barley 
      malts and fine whole hops of several varieties, creating a brew with a full, 
      rich and hearty character. | 
  
   
    | Mad Elf Ale | 
    Troegs  | 
    Harrisburg, PA | 
    11.0 | 
    The combination of Cherries, Honey, and Chocolate Malts delivers gentle 
      fruits and subtle spices. Fermented and aged with a unique yeast , this 
      ruby red beer has significant warming strength that underlies the character 
      of this Ale.  | 
  

A full house at the Loving Arms

Doug, Jean, 
  Bill (note Mardi Gras beads) and Brad listen as first-timer Kathy asks a technical 
  question
 

Brad deep in 
  thought searching for the perfect words to describe the flavor he just tasted
 

Curtis and Cait put the final touches on their ratings, while 
  Russ and Lindsey await the next round
 

Tom, Chris O', Chris M, and Gabe ----- Hmmmm
 

The happy crowd
 
The results of the tasting are presented below. The crowd favorite 
  was Anderson Valley's Winter Solstice with an average score of 41.88 out of 
  50. Five panelists gave it their highest score. Sierra Nevada Celebration finished 
  second with a 39.10 followed by locally brewed Clipper City Winter Storm at 
  38.82. Bell's Winter White Ale was at the bottom of the pack with a score of 
  26.08. Seven panelists rated it as their least favorite.
   
    | Taster | 
    Stoudt's Winter Ale | 
    Smutty-nose Winter Ale | 
    Winter-braun | 
    Bells Winter White Ale | 
    Snow-cap | 
    Winter Solstice Ale | 
    Rogue: Santa's Private Reserve | 
    Winter Storm | 
    Celebra-tion Ale | 
    Mad Elf Ale | 
    Taster Liked Best | 
    Taster liked Least | 
      | 
  
   
    | Doug | 
    40 | 
    40 | 
    24 | 
    11 | 
    21 | 
    22 | 
    23 | 
    30 | 
    28 | 
    27 | 
    Stoudts,Smutty | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Brad | 
    45 | 
    45 | 
    39 | 
    34 | 
    38 | 
    46 | 
    43 | 
       | 
      | 
      | 
    W Solstice | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Bill K | 
    40 | 
    35 | 
    33 | 
    26 | 
    39 | 
    40 | 
    37 | 
    43 | 
    42 | 
    42 | 
    W Storm | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Kathy | 
    30 | 
    21 | 
    28 | 
    25 | 
    38 | 
    45 | 
    39 | 
    40 | 
    35 | 
    48 | 
    Mad Elf | 
    Smuttynose | 
      | 
  
   
    | Curtis | 
    33 | 
    36 | 
    19 | 
    14 | 
    27 | 
    50 | 
    40 | 
    38 | 
    39 | 
    31 | 
    W Solstice | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Russ | 
    41 | 
    36 | 
    32 | 
    33 | 
    30 | 
    38 | 
    35 | 
    37 | 
    37 | 
    39 | 
    Stoudts | 
    Snowcap | 
      | 
  
   
    | Cait | 
    42 | 
    27 | 
    39 | 
    12 | 
    27 | 
    46 | 
    23 | 
    40 | 
    38 | 
    25 | 
    W Solstice | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Lindsey | 
    41 | 
    33 | 
    34 | 
    36 | 
    29 | 
    41 | 
    26 | 
    44 | 
    45 | 
    35 | 
    Celebration | 
    Rogue: SPR | 
      | 
  
   
    | Gabe | 
    42 | 
    40 | 
    42 | 
    32 | 
    38 | 
    44 | 
    36 | 
    42 | 
    45 | 
    39 | 
    Celebration | 
    Bells | 
      | 
  
   
    | Chris M | 
    33 | 
    38 | 
    40 | 
    35 | 
    36 | 
    44 | 
    28 | 
    41 | 
    43 | 
    44 | 
    W Solstice, Mad Elf | 
    Rogue: SPR | 
      | 
  
   
    | Chris 0' | 
    39 | 
    34 | 
    40 | 
    32 | 
    44 | 
    47.5 | 
    30 | 
    37 | 
    39 | 
    44 | 
    W Solstice | 
    Rogue: SPR | 
      | 
  
   
    | Tom | 
    38 | 
    35 | 
    41 | 
    23 | 
    23 | 
    39 | 
      | 
    35 | 
      | 
    27 | 
    Winterbraun | 
    Bells, Snowcap | 
      | 
  
   
    |   | 
    38.67 | 
    35.00 | 
    34.25 | 
    26.08 | 
    32.50 | 
    41.88 | 
    32.73 | 
    38.82 | 
    39.10 | 
    36.45 | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
  
   
    |   | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
    lowest | 
      | 
    highest | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
      | 
  
 
Return to WBAS 
  News
Return 
  to Recent Tastings
Return to WBAS Home